| Year | Name | Team | Awarded From | Position |
| 2016 | Bailey Richards | 1st | IGCA | |
| Casey Jamison | 1st | IGCA | ||
| Dion Shirley | 2nd | IGCA | ||
| 2015 | Bailey Richards | 1st | IGCA | |
| Dion Shirley | 2nd | IGCA | ||
| 2014 | Bailey Richards | 2nd | IGCA | |
| 2013 | Hope Connor | 2nd | IGCA | |
| Bailey Richards | 3rd | IGCA | ||
| 2012 | Aspen Rhodes | 1st | IGCA | Infield |
| Kaytlyn Ernst | 2nd | IGCA | Pitcher | |
| Ana Angel | 2nd | IGCA | Outfield | |
| Dani Hubbard | 3rd | IGCA | Catcher | |
| 2006 | Sina Davis | 3rd | IGHSA | Pitcher |
| 2005 | Sina Davis | 3rd | IGHSA | Pitcher |
| 2003 | Kelsey Maffin | 3rd | IGHSA | Short Stop |
| Sina Davis | 3rd | IGHSA | Pitcher |
