| Year | Name | Team | Awarded From | Position |
| 2016 | Dylan Boles | 1st | Iowa Newspaper Association | UTL D |
| 1st | Des Moines Register | DL | ||
| Sean Boles | 2nd | Iowa Newspaper Association | OL | |
| Carson Rhodes | 2nd | Iowa Newspaper Association | RB | |
| 2015 | Bryce Godwin | 3rd | Iowa Newspaper Association | K |
| Ben Trent | 3rd | Iowa Newspaper Association | QB | |
| 2014 | Cody Blackwell | 3rd | Iowa Newspaper Association | RB |
| 3rd | IowaPreps.com | RB | ||
| 2013 | Spencer Benton | 1st | Des Moines Register | DE |
| 2nd | Iowa Newspaper Association | DL | ||
| 2nd | IowaPreps.com | DL | ||
| Cody Blackwell | 3rd | Iowa Newspaper Association | RB | |
| 3rd | IowaPreps.com | RB | ||
| Brandon Brittain | 1st | Des Moines Register | P | |
| 3rd | Iowa Newspaper Association | QB | ||
| 2nd | IowaPreps.com | UTL | ||
| 1st | SportsSpotlight.com | UTL | ||
| IFCA CLASS 1A Co-Player of the Year – Brandon Brittain | ||||
| Logan Crawford | 3rd | IowaPreps.com | WR | |
| 2nd | SportsSpotlight.com | LB | ||
| Chase Wyant | 2nd | SportsSpotlight.com | DL | |
| 2012 | Tyger Bottenfield | 3rd | Iowa Newspaper Association | WR |
| 1st | IowaPreps.com | WR | ||
| Brandon Brittain | 3rd | IowaPreps.com | UTL | |
| 2nd | SportsSpotlight.com | QB | ||
| Chase Wyant | 3rd | IowaPreps.com | DL | |
| 2011 | Tyger Bottenfield | 3rd | Iowa Newspaper Association | WR |
| 3rd | IowaPreps.com | WR | ||
| 2nd | SportsSpotlight.com | WR | ||
| Brandon Brittain | 3rd | IowaPreps.com | QB | |
| Tyler Reicks | 2nd | Des Moines Register | DB | |
| 2nd | Iowa Newspaper Association | RB | ||
| 3rd | IowaPreps.com | RB | ||
| 1st | SportsSpotlight.com | DB | ||
| 2010 | Marcus Benton | 3rd | Iowa Newspaper Association | DL |
| 3rd | IowaPreps.com | DL | ||
| Tyler Reicks | 2nd | Des Moines Register | DB | |
| 3rd | Iowa Newspaper Association | WR | ||
| 2nd | IowaPreps.com | WR | ||
| 2nd | SportsSpotlight.com | DB | ||
| 2009 | Marcus Benton | 2nd | Des Moines Register | DL |
| 3rd | Iowa Newspaper Association | OL | ||
| Jake Camp | 1st | Iowa Newspaper Association | LB | |
| Ben Fisher | 2nd | SportsSpotlight.com | DB | |
| Michael Plasencia | 2nd | Iowa Newspaper Association | WR | |
| 2008 | Quin Pelz | 3rd | Iowa Newspaper Association | OL |
| 2007 | Isaac Bright | 1st | SportsSpotlight.com | DB |
| Mike Bullis | 3rd | Iowa Newspaper Association | DL | |
| 2006 | Matt VandeKamp | 2nd | Iowa Newspaper Association | DL |
| 2005 | Jake Gionet | 2nd | Des Moines Register | OL |
| 3rd | Iowa Newspaper Association | OL | ||
| 2004 | A.J. Wright | 2nd | Iowa Newspaper Association | DB |
| 2003 | Kyle Edwards | 1st | Des Moines Register | DL |
| 2nd | Iowa Newspaper Association | DL | ||
| Zach Eggleston | 1st | Iowa Newspaper Association | RB | |
| 2001 | Caleb Barber | 2nd | Des Moines Register | SE |
| Todd Michalski | 2nd | Des Moines Register | RB | |
| 2nd | Iowa Newspaper Association | RB | ||
| Nate Mittag | 2nd | Iowa Newspaper Association | QB | |
| 1999 | Nate Shipman | 2nd | Des Moines Register | QB |
| 2nd | Iowa Newspaper Association | QB | ||
| 1998 | Troy Michalski | 2nd | Des Moines Register | DE |
| 1997 | Nic Lyon | 1st | Des Moines Register | QB |
| 1st | Iowa Newspaper Association | QB | ||
| 1996 | Jason Boucher | 2nd | Des Moines Register | OL |
| Chris Draper | 1st | Des Moines Register | LB | |
| Brian Koons | Elite | Des Moines Register | SE | |
| 1st | Des Moines Register | SE | ||
| 1st | Iowa Newspaper Association | SE | ||
| IFCA CLASS 1A Player of the Year – Brian Koons | ||||
| Nic Lyon | 1st | Des Moines Register | QB | |
| 2nd | Iowa Newspaper Association | QB | ||
| Trent Michalski | 3rd | Des Moines Register | DB | |
| 2nd | Iowa Newspaper Association | DB | ||
| John VandeKamp | 2nd | Iowa Newspaper Association | RB | |
| 1995 | Mike Armstrong | 3rd | Des Moines Register | OL |
| Matt Deemer | 1st | Des Moines Register | DL | |
| 1st | Iowa Newspaper Association | DL | ||
| Brian Koons | 1st | Des Moines Register | SE | |
| 2nd | Iowa Newspaper Association | SE | ||
| Justin Koons | 3rd | Des Moines Register | OL | |
| Mark Jimmerson | 2nd | Des Moines Register | DB | |
| 1994 | Brandon Corkrean | 1st | Des Moines Register | QB |
| Elite | Iowa Prep Illustrated | QB | ||
| Matt Deemer | 2nd | Des Moines Register | DL | |
| Brian Koons | Elite | Iowa Prep Illustrated | SE | |
| 1993 | Shawn Dooley | 1st | Des Moines Register | DB |
